When is a goal not a goal?
When James Magner kicked what appeared to be a fortuitous goal in the second term, it soon became a subject for video adjudication. His kick bounced under the foot of Tiger ruckman Ivan Maric, and seemingly moved in an off-break fashion for a goal. But, after deliberation, it was deemed a behind. Coach Mark Neeld was pragmatic in his thoughts when pressed about it post-match. “I looked at that video and couldn’t tell. You can’t tell and you’re not sure, so that’s what it’s there for. The lesser score stands if you’re not sure, and we know that going in. As soon as I saw the tape, you go ‘Gee, I’m not really sure there.’ The obvious adjudication is a behind and we know that, so that’s ok.”
Inaccuracy saves Demons
Aside from Melbourne’s two wins this season, the result on Saturday was its third ‘best’ loss - in terms of margins. But its 23-point defeat could have been much worse, considering Richmond had 36 scoring shots to 23. Although the Tigers only kicked two more goals than the Demons, they registered 23 behinds to 12. There is no doubt that Melbourne has lost by more this season and produced better performances.
Dees save best for last
One of the most frustrating aspects of Melbourne’s loss was that it had 12 scoring shots to seven in the final term. Not only did the Demons win the quarter by 15 points, they kicked six goals - the best effort by either team in a term during the match. Up until three quarter time, the Demons had 11 scoring shots and 5.6 on the board, as Richmond held a 38-point lead heading into the final term. The Demons also won the second term by four points, capping off an inconsistent day.
Jones keeps on keeping on
The midfielder has been one of Melbourne’s bright sparks in a disappointing season. He regularly produces consistent performances and, after missing the last round against the Brisbane Lions with a calf injury, returned to be one of Melbourne’s best against Richmond. Champion Data rated him the red and blue’s best. But, despite the ball winner collecting 25 disposals, he acknowledged it was hard to come back from missing a rare match. “It was ok. Having a week off, I really felt it. I’m just looking to play my role for the team and I’m just looking forward to another win. I’m sick of losing, but now we’ll hopefully bounce back,” he told melbournefc.com.au.
And now to Etihad Stadium
Melbourne has lost its past 12 matches at Etihad Stadium and has not won there since round 19, 2007, when Mark Riley was coach. In fact, the Demons have won two of their past 21 matches at Docklands - a terrible record. That dates back to round 16, 2005, when the Sydney Swans defeated Melbourne, then under coach Neale Daniher. On Saturday, the Demons take on the Dockers. It won’t be an easy match, but it would be a strong step forward, if Melbourne can overcome Fremantle at Docklands.
